"Plant selection may have to review, the background stem plant combination is OK, however, different leaf shape not harmonized on right hand middle ground. The gravel not natural arranged on foreground, review more aquascape master layout how they arrange gravel could help to improve."

- Gary Wu

"

The layout has a very sharp impression from the sand area in the foreground to the stem plants area in the background. The shadow of the stones in the middle ground tightens the overall impression of this layout, and the contrast with the bright plants is wonderful. However, the balance between the left and right sides of the composition is similar and the overall symmetry needs improvement.

- Takayuki Fukada